Pulling Rabbits Out Of A Hat! 10 November 2023
The week’s 1,782 real estate and properties transactions totalled US$ 2.02 billion, during the week ending 10 November 2023. The sum of transactions was 396 plots, sold for US$ 1.09 billion, and 1,386 apartments and villas, selling for US$ 929 million. The top three transactions were all for plots of land, the first in Me’aisem Second for US$ 34 million, Al Safouh Second for US$ 26 million and in Wadi Al Safa 2 for US$ 24 million. Wadi Al Safa 2 recorded the most transactions, with seventy-nine sales, worth US$ 146 million, followed by seventy-three sales, in Palm Jabal Ali, for US$ 441 million, and sixty-one sales in Me’aisem Second valued at US$ 202 million. The top three transfers for apartments and villas were for a villa in Dubai Marina for US$ 98 million, another in Palm Jumeirah, sold for US$ 14 million, and an apartment in Me’aisem First for US$ 12 million. The mortgaged properties for the week reached US$ 507 million; one hundred and forty-two properties were granted between first-degree relatives worth US$ 272 million.
Knight Frank’s latest report points to a 5% property price rise in Dubai’s prime market, (including The Palm Jumeirah, Emirates Hills and Jumeirah Bay Island), next year, driven by supply limitations and resurgence in demand from key source markets such as China and India; prices in other segments of the residential market are projected to grow at 3.5%. To this observer, it seems far too conservative and will only occur if regional troubles escalate. Dubai’s prime markets are responsible for 4.8% of transactions by the total value in the first nine months of 2023. In Q3, average residential property prices expanded 19% on an annual basis and 5% on the quarter, with villa and apartment annual prices up 18% and 19%; since Q1 2020, the cumulative increase has hit 30%.
In the six months to 30 September, the ready homes market and off plan sales almost ran in tandem – 51.2:48.8 – (US$ 28.58 billion:US$ 27.25 billion). In Q3, segment-wise, Jumeirah Islands posted a 73% annual price hike at US$ 730 per sq ft – the strongest growth for villas. Meanwhile, for apartments, Dubai South led the field with growth of 73% followed by Jumeirah Lakes Towers (67%) and Umm Suqeim Third, (37%); on a quarterly basis, prices were up 33% in Dubai South.
The study also noted that currently, there were 77.9k homes (excluding branded residences) under construction, scheduled for delivery by the end of 2028, with an annual average of approximately 13k homes over the next six years, considerably below historical completion rates. However, this figure will be supplemented by a raft of new launches, with many of them handed over within a thirty-month period. Previous blogs have indicated that by the end of 2023, Dubai will have a portfolio of some 800k housing units and an expected population of some 3.65 million – an increase of around 100k this year; the ratio of apartments to villas is in the region of 85:15. A quick estimate would see the approximate household size being 4.56 people per household, with recent trends showing that this ratio is declining. That being the case, and assuming the size drops to 4.35 and the population grows at a conservative 3% over the next decade, to 4.9 million, the number of units in 2033 should be 1.126 million; this equates to an extra 326k units or 32.6k a year. However, the population growth estimate could be on the low side, bearing in mind that pre-Covid, Dubai’s population was growing at annual double-digit rates.
Official data reports that residential transactions in Dubai, in the ten months to 31 October, reached 93.6k and has already surpassed 2022’s record total transactions of 92.2k for the twelve months. The month of October saw a 23.6% decline in the number of transactions tom 6.4k; although secondary market transactions grew 29.5%, off-plan deals fell by 57.2%.
Meanwhile Valustrat posted that its Q3 property index, (VPI), reached its highest quarterly capital gains in a decade; it grew a record 6.1%, on the quarter, and 15.1% higher on the year, to reach 96.6 points. Villa valuations surpassed peaks seen in 2014 by 2.6%, with villa prices increasing over the twelve months, by 19.8% and 7.6% on the quarter to reach 123.6 VPI points. The leading four performers were Palm Jumeirah (9.5%), Jumeirah Islands (9.5%), Dubai Hills Estate (9.3%), and Mudon (9.0%). The VPI for apartments also posted record capital gains, up 4.8% on the quarter, and 11.0% on the year, to reach 79.7 points – 29.2% below peaks of 2014. The highest quarterly performers were Discovery Gardens (7.5%), The Greens (7.3%), Palm Jumeirah (6.7%), and Dubailand Residence Complex (6.6%).
Dubai’s average residential prices increased by 19.1%in the year to October 2023, marginally down from the 19.6% rate of growth registered a month earlier. Over the same period, average apartment and villa prices rose by 18.7% and 21.4%, respectively. In October 2023, average apartment prices stood at US$ 372 per sq ft, and average villa prices stood at US$ 449 per sq ft. Although the average apartment sales rates per sq ft still sit at 8.3% below the 2014 high, a number of communities have already topped their 2014 levels. On the other hand, the average villa sales rates have surpassed their 2014 figures by 14.1%. In the apartment segment of the market, Downtown Dubai recorded the highest sales rate at US$ 681 per sq ft, whereas, in the villa segment of the market, Palm Jumeirah recorded the highest sales rate at US$ 1,396 per sq ft.
In line with recent months there has been a slowdown in growth rates exemplified by October’s annual rise of 19.7% compared to 20.6% a month earlier. Over this period, average apartment rents rose by 19.9%, and average villa rents grew by 18.0%. As at October 2023, the average yearly apartment and villa asking rents stood at US$ 30.0k and US$ 88.0k respectively. The highest yearly apartment and villa rents were respectively found in Palm Jumeirah, with average rents at US$ 69.8k, and in Al Barari, where average rents reached US$ 298.9k.
There is no doubt that Dubai residential property prices have a long way to go before they catch up with other major global cities. Q3 was the eleventh consecutive quarter of growth in the sector and there are many analysts that see no immediate end to this trend; the fact that supply is still lagging behind demand is another reason for price growth to continue. Knight Frank has calculated that US$ 1 million will buy the following sq mt pf prime property:
- Monaco 17 sq mt
- New York 33 sq mt
- Singapore 34 sq mt
- London 34 sq mt
- Sydney 44 sq mt
- Shanghai 44 sq mt
- Tokyo 60 sq mt
- Berlin 70 sq mt
- Dubai 105 sq mt
The 64-storey, 302 mt, Wasl Tower, set to be completed by Q3 2024, will be one of the world’s tallest buildings to use ceramic fins as a renewable means to achieve energy efficiency. As a matter of coincidence, 2023 is UAE’s Year of Sustainability and the upcoming global climate summit COP 28 will be held in Dubai later in the month. Noting that the construction sector drives over 33% of global annual greenhouse gas emissions, Wasl Tower’s CEO commented that the building “represents our continuous efforts to innovate and create smarter, more sustainable developments that meet the evolving needs of people and the UAE’s climate goals.” The new building further enhances Dubai’s credentials as a global leader in adopting state-of-the-art sustainability solutions in the construction sector. The building will fulfil contemporary requirements for safety, sustainability and energy efficiency, with the ceramic fins providing shade, boost wind-induced cooling and indirectly channel daylight deep into the building’s interior. The massive mixed-use project, spanning a built-up area of around 167.8k sq mt, will feature apartments, offices, restaurants, a luxurious 259-key Mandarin Oriental hotel and a swimming pool.
Vincitore Realty unveiled Vincitore Aqua Dimore —its sixth project in Dubai – with a US$ 327 million development value which it hopes to redefine affordable luxury and help attract more buyers and investors to the market. The project offers the luxury of aqua resort living in one’s own branded residence – that buyers can avail with an affordable price. It will encompass branded designer apartments, ranging from Palatial Studio, 1 BR, 2 BR and 3 BR, with designer private pool; completion is slated for Q4 2026. Prices of apartments start from US$ 189k for a studio, with a 1% monthly payment plan available; the developer also offers an 8.0% guaranteed net return on investment for the first three years.
The fact that the six GCC states have unanimously approved a regional unified tourism visa will add another positive driver for Dubai’s hospitality sector which will greatly benefit from this initiative; it is expected to become operational by 2025. The decision is expected to streamline travel logistics and underpins the “continuous communication and co-ordination” between the GCC states and will obviously facilitate the movement of residents and tourists around the bloc. It will also provide a boost to the tourism sector. At the same meeting, it was agreed to introduce the electronic linking of traffic offences between GCC states and to prepare a comprehensive strategy to combat illegal drugs.
October’s seasonally adjusted S&P Global PMI shows that business activity in Dubai’s non-oil private sector economy improved further, rising 1.3 to 57.4, as business optimism soared, and sales hit a four-year high. New business intakes increased at their quickest rate in over four years, encompassing most key sectors, specifically among wholesale and retail companies, as well as travel and tourism service providers. Economic activity was driven by surging market demand and growing confidence, as there was a faster increase in new business volumes, with businesses surveyed reporting new clients and an improvement in market demand. New order inflows will continue to grow and drive activity expansion, as companies also increased their inventories build-up, whilst there was only a slight rise in October employment.
HH Sheikh Mohammed has approved both Dubai’s budgets, for 2024 – 2026, and also Law No 20 of 2023 for the general budget for the fiscal year 2024; the emirate’s three-year budget sees expenditure totalling US$ 67.19 billion and for next year US$ 21.55 billion. It plans to raise public revenue of US$ 24.69 billion in 2024, of which US$ 23.19 billion has been allocated to the budget and US$ 1.50 billion to the general reserve. The budget indicates Dubai’s aim to stimulate the macroeconomy and support the objectives of the Dubai Strategic Plan 2030 development project, as well as the Dubai Economic Agenda D33. The Media Office also noted that the three-year budget has several targets including “to boost entrepreneurship, attract more foreign investment, promote social welfare, support fields like space research, digitisation and artificial intelligence, and consolidate the emirate’s position as a “land of opportunity and innovation”. The Crown Prince, Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed, commented that “the financial sustainability, competitiveness and transparency embedded in this budget will make Dubai even more appealing to investors and businesses from across the world seeking new opportunities.”
Budget expenditure has been allocated:
- 42% – infrastructure, (including roads, tunnels, bridges, transport, sewage stations, parks, renewable energy sources and waste treatment facilities)
- 34% – social development, (including health, education, scientific research, housing, care for needy families and women and children, reading, translation and programming initiatives, development of youth and sports, care for senior citizens and retirees, and care for people of determination)
- 19% – the security, justice and safety sector
- 5% – supporting the public services sector, government excellence, creativity, innovation and scientific research to develop performance and foster a culture of excellence, innovation and creativity
It is hoped that the establishment of a general reserve from annual revenues will top US$ 5.60 billion for the three years 2024-2026, with an expectation that the operating surplus would equate to 3.3% of Dubai’s GDP, during the three-year financial plan.
The UAE’s Vice President and Ruler of Dubai has unveiled a ten-point document with an ambitious plan to develop the country’s economy making it the best in the world. The guiding principles of the ‘Economic Principles of UAE’, are to present the country as an integrated economy backed by a fully developed digital infrastructure, secure systems and adaptable legislation. The ten principles cover:
- Globally open free-market economy
- Attracting top talent
- Digital economy
- Nurturing the youth
- Sustainable and balanced economy
- Strong and stable financial system
- Strong and fair legislative environment
- Transparency and laws
- Strong banking sector
- Transport and logistics infrastructure
Following directives from Dubai’s Crown Prince, Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed, the DFF and the Dubai Centre for Artificial Intelligence have been tasked to organise the Global Prompt Engineering Championship in May 2024. The two-day event, to be held at the Museum of the Future, will be the largest challenge of its kind to leverage the power of Generative AI, and will feature a prize pool of US$ 272k (AED 1 million); it will include three main categories – literature, art and coding. It is expected that such an event will enhance Dubai as a destination for Generative AI talent and for entrepreneurs, as well as a centre for developing a new generation of innovations associated with prompt engineering. The Crown Prince reiterated the emirate’s commitment to nurture an exceptional programming community which will include attracting top talent and experts to drive innovation.
At yesterday’s Executive Council meeting, its chairman, Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohammed approved several transformative initiatives to stimulate the emirate’s economy, including incentives targeted at doubling the contribution of industrial and agricultural technology sectors to Dubai’s economy by 2033, as well as plans to progressively phase out single-use plastics by 2026. He reiterated the pivotal role of a diversified economy in achieving the ambitious objectives outlined in the Dubai Economic Agenda D33, which seeks to propel Dubai into the ranks of the world’s top three cities by 2033. He commented that “these steps represent significant measures to expand the contribution of agriculture to Dubai’s diverse economy by doubling the size of the sector. We call on investors, experts and innovators to join our global platform for research, development and innovation.”
Next week sees Dubai World Trade Centre once again being the location for the twenty-fifth Water, Energy, Technology and Environment exhibition, and Dubai Solar Show, organised by DEWA under the directives of HH Sheikh Mohammed. WETEX and DSS 2023, running from 15 – 17 November, will host twenty-four international pavilions from sixteen countries, as well as seventy-five sponsors and thirty-seven partners and supporting associations.
UAE authorities have issued guidelines relating to the importance of complying with anti-money laundering regulations and the need to combat the use of unlicensed virtual asset service providers. The main targets will not only be the financial institutions but also the general public being told why compliance is so important when it comes to AML and the negative impact it can have on both the local and global economies. Not only will VASPs, operating without a licence, face civil and criminal penalties but also all parties dealing with them. The guidelines were drawn up by the National Anti-Money Laundering and Combatting Financing of Terrorism and Financing of Illegal Organisations Committee (NAMLCFTC).
Following increased demand, the Mohammed Bin Rashid Aerospace Hub announced the expansion of three new facilities:
aerospace supply chain includes a 22k sq mt expansion for use by engine shops, component and landing gear MROs and workshop solutions for SMEs
suppliers complex a second landslide facility to the first vertical aerospace complex in the region will add 13k sq mt of light industrial space to enable aerospace companies, mainly SMEs and start-ups to set up their facilities easily and quickly
line maintenance units the second phase will feature an airside plot which supports airside operators, including FBOs, to have direct access to clients; it will feature nine units that offer one-stop-optimal aviation-related solutions, such as maintenance warehouse facilities, tooling and engineering
All the above facilities are slated for completion starting in Q4 2024, with 70% of the area pre-leased by global companies attracted by MBRAH from abroad.
According to the travel analysis company ForwardKeys, the UAE ranked eighth among the top ten tourism destinations globally that have seen the strongest growth in international visitors in 2023, as compared to pre-pandemic 2019. From the list, it can be seen that the “sun and sea” destinations were favoured – the Dominican Republic, Colombia, Mexico and Greece. The report confirmed that international tourism continues to recover after the pandemic, but data indicated that globally, tourist arrivals showed “significant differences” between regions, with Africa and the ME being the only worldwide switching from recovery to growth in Q4; YTD, international tourist arrivals were 14% below pre-pandemic levels, but are set to grow 2% this quarter. With Saudi Arabia fifth, UAE eighth and Egypt tenth on the list, the region was well represented. The UAE posted YTD international tourist arrivals 14% below pre-pandemic levels, which are expected to grow 2% in Q4. On a global scale, numbers are 27% shy on 2019 but are expected to be nearer 13% below pre-pandemic returns by the end of this year – with one caveat, that the current crisis involving Israel does not spill over.
The Emirates Group has posted its best ever six-month financial results for fiscal H1 ending 30 September, with net profit 138% higher, at US$ 2.75 billion, driven by a 20% hike in revenue to US$ 18.34 billion, attributable to strong demand for air transport across the world, since the last pandemic travel restrictions were lifted. It also reported an EBITDA of US$ 5.61 billion, a significant 34.6% uptick compared to H1 2022. Its cash position stood US$ 11.63 billion, marginally higher than the 31 March balance, whilst it has repaid US$ 2.50 billion of its Covid-related loans, as well as a 2022-23 dividend payment US$ 1.23 billion, (AED 4.5 billion), to its owner. Its payroll has increased by 6.0% to 109k, with both Emirates and dnata have ongoing recruitment drives to support their future requirements. The carrier’s chairman, Sheikh Ahmed bin Saeed, posted that “this is a tremendous achievement that speaks to the talent and commitment within the organisation, the strength of our business model, and power of Dubai’s vision and policies that has enabled the creation of a strong, resilient, and progressive aviation sector.” He also noted that “for the second half of 2023-24, we expect customer demand across our business divisions to remain healthy and we will stay agile in how we deploy our resources in this dynamic marketplace. At the same time, we are keeping a close watch on headwinds such as rising fuel prices, the strengthening US dollar, inflationary costs, and geo-politics.”
The airline profit rose 135% to a new record of US$ 2.56 billion, as revenue, including other operating income, of US$ 16.21 billion was up 18.8% on the year. Passenger numbers were 31.0% higher at 26.1 million, compared to H1 2022. Despite an overall softening in the global cargo market, Emirates Skycargo uplifted 1.35 million tonnes in H1 – 11.0% higher than a year earlier.
The government has announced that its fifth auction of Islamic Treasury Sukuks was 5.2 times oversubscribed, with bids received for the US$ 409 million, (AED 1.5 billion) issue, totalling US$ 1.57 billion, (AED 5.77 billion). As with the previous four auctions this year, there were two tranches – two-year and three-year – with a spread of 4 to 11 bps over US Treasuries with similar maturities.
An unnamed money exchange operating in the UAE has been fined US$ 1.30 million over its “weak compliance framework” to prevent money laundering and the financing of terrorism. Evidently it failed to have the “required risk analysis” and due diligence policies and procedures in place. The Central Bank of the UAE imposed the financial sanction as per the federal law.
DEWA reported an 8.0% increase in Q3 net profit, to US$ 910 million, driven by an increase in demand for the utility’s electricity, water and cooling services, and despite its finance costs doubling to US$ 134 million; revenue rose more than 10% to US$ 2.57 billion. In the nine-month period, profit fell by 4% to about US$ 1.63 billion, while revenue gained more than 7%. The public utility is expected to pay out its US$ 845 million H2 dividend next April. MD, Saeed Al Tayer, commented that “DEWA’s shareholder strategy is focused on delivering consistent returns, upholding [the] highest environmental, social, and governance (ESG) standards and delivering sustainable growth.” In Q3, total power generation was up 9.3% to nearly 19 terawatt-hours, and water desalination, at 38.7 billion imperial gallons, was 5% higher; by the end of September, it served more than 1.2 million customers.
Emaar Properties posted a 42% hike in nine-month net profit to US$ 2.23 billion, as revenue dipped 3.0% to US$ 5.01 billion, whilst group property sales posted a 16.0% increase to US$ 8.47 billion. By the end of the period, Emaar’s revenue backlog topped nearly US$ 19.0 billion. In June, its long-term issuer credit rating was upgraded one notch to ‘BBB’ by S&P Global Rating.
Meanwhile, its majority-owned subsidiary, Emaar Development, posted property sales of US$ 7.87 billion – 25% higher on the year; the unit, which specialises in build-to-sell property development business, recorded revenue figures of US$ 2.01 billion, with EBITDA 36% higher at US$ 1.23 billion. Its shopping mall, retail, and commercial leasing operations posted a revenue of US$ 1.17 billion, with its mall assets recording an average 97% occupancy rate. Recurring revenue from malls, hospitality, leisure, entertainment, and commercial leasing rose 26% annually to US$ 1.85 billion. Emaar’s hospitality, leisure, and entertainment divisions generated a 22% rise in revenue to US$ 681 million, attributable to a steady recovery in the tourism sector and strong domestic spending. Emaar’s UAE hotels, including those under management, reported an average 70% occupancy in the period. Emaar’s international real estate operations, which represent more than 11% of Emaar’s total revenue, recorded property sales of US$ 599 illion with revenue totalling US$ 572 million during the period, mainly driven by operations in Egypt and India.
Al Ansari Financial Services announced a US$ 106 million profit for the first nine months of 2023, with the Group operating income 1.5% higher at US$ 235 million, helped by a 10% increase in demand across all other products and services. As indicated last week, a US$ 82 million, (AED 300 million), dividend was approved, in line with the commitment posted in its IPO earlier in the year which equates to a 7.0% dividend yield. A further similar amount will be paid in April. Group CEO, Rashed A Al Ansari noted that “we take great pride in outperforming the market across all our products and offerings, as well as in our unwavering commitment to achieving our growth targets.”
Aramex posted Q3 declines in both revenue and net profit by 5.6% to US$ 368 million and by 76.0% to short of US$ 3 million respectively, largely attributable to soaring interest rates, (accounting for almost 50% of the decline in net income), forex fluctuations and a slowing global economy. Operating profit was 12.0% lower at US$ 12 million. For the first nine months of the year saw revenue falling 5.0% to US$ 1.13 billion and net profit 60.0% lower at US$ 14 million. Aramex’s international express business posted a 4.0% annual rise in revenue to US$ 140 million, despite a 5.0% decline in shipment volumes due to the slowdown in retail activity; gross profit came in 20.0% higher to US$ 50 million.
The DFM opened on Monday, 06 November 2023, 143 points higher the previous week, gained 212 points (4.8%) to close the trading week on 3,969, by Friday 10 November 2023. Emaar Properties, US$ 0.14 higher the previous week, gained US$ 0.01 to close on US$ 1.87 by the end of the week. DEWA, Emirates NBD, DIB and DFM started the previous week on US$ 0.65, US$ 4.80, US$ 1.48, and US$ 0.37 and closed on US$ 0.65, US$ 4.81, US$ 1.51 and US$ 0.37. On 10 November, trading was at 111 million shares, with a value of US$ 96 million, compared to 112 million shares, with a value of US$ 69 million, on 03 November 2023.
By Friday, 10 November 2023, Brent, US$ 7.08 lower (7.7%) the previous fortnight, shed US$ 3.85 (4.6%) to close on US$ 81.30. Gold, US$ 16 (0.8%) lower the previous week, shed US$ 57 (2.9%) to trade at US$ 1,943 by 10 November 2023.
With an order backlog approaching 8k commercial planes at the end of Q3, Airbus posted a 12% rise in revenue to US$ 15.89 billion, with Q3 profit 21% higher at US$ 862 million, on the back of increased demand and a hike in jet deliveries; adjusted profit before interest and tax rose 21% on an annual basis to US$ 1.08 billion. For the first nine months of the year, although revenue was 12% higher, at US$ 45.41 billion, net profit dipped 9% to US$ 2.49 billion, with its gross commercial aircraft orders totalling 1.28k, 49.5% higher compared to the same period in 2022. It delivered 488 commercial aircraft during the period, up 11.6%, comprising 41 A220s, 391 A320 Family, 20 A330s and 36 A350s. Airbus Helicopters posted a 22.4% decline in net orders to 191 units, with defence and space division’s order value climbing 6.2% to US$ 9.07 billion. Guillaume Faury, chief executive of Airbus, commented that “we continue to make progress on our operational plan in a global environment that has become increasingly complex,” and that “we expect the supply chain to remain challenging as we progress on the production ramp-up.”
Ryanair posted a near 60% hike in H1 profits to US$ 2.18 billion, driven by an 11% rise in passenger numbers, to 105.4 million, and a 24% hike in average fares, to US$ 58. The no-frills carrier’s chief executive, Michael O’Leary, noted that this was “due to a very strong Easter and record summer traffic”, despite higher fuel costs. The airline sees fares rising by “mid-teens percentage” during Q4 and prior to Christmas. It expects full year profits to hover around US$ 2.0 billion – an indicator that many airlines tend to lose money over the winter period.
Last January, Greenpeace managed to board a Shell production vessel near the Canary Islands to protest oil drilling and travelled on it as far as Norway. This week, the tech giant filed a US$ 2.1 million claim in damages in what it said was boarding a moving vessel at sea was “unlawful and extremely dangerous.” Shell is seeking damages that include costs related to shipping delays and expenses for extra security, as well as legal costs. There are reports that Shell offered to reduce its damage claim to US$ 1.4 million if Greenpeace’s activists agree not to protest again at any of Shell’s oil and gas infrastructure at sea or in port.
If British Steel’s plans to close its Scunthorpe blast furnaces go through, there is the possibility that up to 2k will lose their jobs; China’s Jingye Group wants to introduce two electric furnaces, (one at Scunthorpe and the other in Teesside), to transform the company into a “green and sustainable company”. A US$ 620 million, (GBP 500), taxpayer rescue package – similar to the one availed to Tata – may save jobs. However, blast furnace plants are not economic – reportedly losing US$ 1.24 million a day – and are not “green” and could be unsustainable on both financial and environmental grounds. Electric arc furnaces are mostly used to melt down and repurpose scrap steel, and the finished product is not the same grade of steel as that produced in blast furnaces and is not suitable for all industrial uses. Its main advantage appears to be that they run at lower temperatures and can use electricity generated by renewables.
Alleging tax evasion, an Italian judge has ordered the seizure of US$ 840 million from Airbnb, over tax evasion, with claims that the short-term rental firm failed to collect tax from landlords of around US$ 3.95 billion of rental income; landlords in Italy are required to pay a 21% tax on their earnings. It is also reported that three former managers, who held managerial roles at Airbnb from 2017 to 2021, were also under investigation. The US giant, which has operated in the country for the past fifteen years, commented that it had been trying since June to resolve the issue and that “we are confident that we have acted in full compliance with the law and intend to exercise our rights with respect to this issue.” In recent years, Italian authorities have increased scrutiny of the tax practices of major companies like Airbnb and have also launched tax-related inquiries against Netflix and Meta. It is estimated that if authorities could collect the “missing tax” from landlords, it could add US$ 1.09 billion to public funds.
In 2016, the EC decided Apple had received unfair preferential treatment from the Irish government, allowing it to pay a much lower rate of tax than other companies, commenting that this constituted illegal aid given to the tech giant by the Irish state; the figure that Apple is claiming not to pay is estimated at US$ 13.88 billion. This was overturned on appeal. Three years ago, a ruling which found Apple had been given illegal tax breaks by the Irish government was overturned, but a year later, the lower court, known as the General Court, ruled that the EC’s decision that Apple should pay back taxes was legally flawed and should be set aside, but that ruling itself could now be overturned after the latest twist. This week, Advocate General Giovanni Pitruzzella, at the Court of Justice, said the case should be reviewed again. The argument was that a series of legal errors had been made and the ruling in Apple’s favour had failed “to assess correctly the substance and consequences of certain methodological errors that, according to the Commission decision, vitiated the tax rulings”. The Irish government had argued that Apple should not have to repay the back taxes, deeming that its loss was worth it to make the country an attractive home for large companies – the country is Apple’s base for the EMEA. The battle goes on.
San Francisco is the location of a court battle between the maker of the popular video game Fortnite and Google which is accused of acting as a monophyly by charging 30% commission on in-app purchases on Google Play store. The tech giant refutes such claims, saying that it competes with Apple, and that there was an abundance of ways to download apps on Android phones. Epic argued that Google has “eliminated competition in the distribution of Android apps using myriad contractual and technical barriers.” On the other side of the country, in Washington, the US Justice Department is accusing Google of holding an illegal monopoly over search. In 2020, Fortnite was pulled from Google Play and the App Store on the grounds that they considered charges to be “taxes” on developers.
Data by CoinGecko has indicated that global assets invested in exchange-traded funds, tied to the spot price of bitcoin, now total US$ 4.16 billion, of which seven spot bitcoin ETFs, that had been launched in Canada since 2021, account for US$ 2.0 billion of the total; the largest of the ETFs, at US$ 819 million, is Canada’s Purpose Bitcoin ETF. There is some reticence among US legislators about ETFs and to date only those tied to future contracts, are allowed; the largest is ProShares Bitcoin Strategy which has about US$ 1.2 billion in assets. The SEC has so far denied all spot bitcoin ETF applications, saying applicants have not shown they can protect investors from market manipulation. Germany started the ball rolling in Europe in June 2020, with ETC Group Physical Bitcoin, now the second d largest ever launched with a value of US$ 802 million. Europe has seven other ETFs, mostly incorporated in tax havens such as Jersey, the Cayman Islands and Liechtenstein, with much smaller products traded in Brazil and Australia.
The so-called “King of Crypto”, 31-year-old Sam Bankman-Fried, who once ran one of the world’s biggest cryptocurrency exchanges, has been found guilty of seven counts of fraud and money laundering by a New York court and now faces decades of incarceration. He was arrested late last year, after his cryptocurrency exchange FTX went bankrupt, with a reported US$ 8.0 billion worth of customers’ funds missing. FTX was once valued at US$ 32.0 billion. The jury found him guilty of lying to investors and lenders and stealing billions of dollars from FTX, helping to precipitate its collapse. The prosecution presented evidence that Bankman-Fried’s crypto trading firm Alameda Research received deposits on behalf of FTX customers from the early days of the exchange, when traditional banks were unwilling to let it open an account. Instead of safeguarding those funds, as Bankman-Fried repeatedly pledged to do in public, he used the money to repay Alameda lenders, buy property and make investments and political donations.
On Wednesday, some ten million Australians, 40% of the population, could not use smartphones, broadband internet or landlines for much of the day. The problem was an outage at Optus that started at 4.00 am, with services only being restored at 5.30 pm, during which time payment, transport and health systems were thrown into chaos. Communications Minister Michelle Rowland commented that no cause of the failure was given but “it has occurred deep within the network (and) it has wide ramifications across mobile, fixed, and broadband services for Optus customers”, and added that “customers are clearly frustrated about it and Optus should respond to that accordingly.” Optus, owned by Singapore Telecommunications, reported one of the country’s biggest cyber breaches fourteen months ago, and with this latest incident questions are being asked about the fragility of the country’s core infrastructure. After this debacle, the Albanese government will have to look closely to ensure that if this sort of outage occurs again, the infrastructure across multiple private companies can cope.
There will not be too many tears shed for the ex-boss of NatWest, Dame Alison Rose, will lose out on a US$ 9.3 million payout after she had not been given “good leaver” status after she had admitted to discussing the closure of Nigel Farage’s bank account. If she had, Dame Alison would have been entitled to receive the entire amount which, after including her yearly salary, would have exceeded US$ 12 million; she will receive her US$ 3 million fixed pay package, but will not benefit from share awards and bonuses she had previously been entitled to. The UK government used to be a majority shareholder in the bank but since 2022 now has a 38% stake. Paying out huge sums for not doing your job properly will impact the UK taxpayer, with NatWest agreeing to a maximum US$ 482k towards her legal costs.
In the UK, the number of people falling behind on their mortgage payments in Q3 increased 18% to 88.0k, compared to the same period in 2022, with the number among landlords almost doubling. The number of homeowners in arrears was up 7% in Q3 on the year. It is obvious that soaring interest rates are the main reason behind these figures. Surprisingly, it is reported that the number where payments have fallen behind still represent just 1% of the 8.8 million outstanding mortgages; it seems that those in distress tend to pay their mortgages ahead of other liabilities or expenses. However, with an estimated 1.6 million mortgage payers expected to be paying more in 2023, after their fixed rates become variable, there will be more arrears.
Latest UK GDP figures indicated that September’s GDP was 0.2% higher, but over Q3, growth was at zero. In September, the services sector was the largest upward contributor to the economy, nudging up 0.2%, with consumer-facing services down 0.2% in September and 0.7% lower in August, with declines noted in health, management consultancy and commercial property rentals; these were offset by growth in engineering, car sales and machinery leasing. According to the BoE, which correctly forecast (for a change) stagflation in the period, is now expecting much of the same in Q4. Such figures may see no further interest rate hikes, but there is a slight possibility of recession – if not, then the country will be in a state of stagflation well into 2024. There is no doubt that the country is in disarray, (as is the Sunak government), and later in the month, Jeremy Hunt, the Chancellor will deliver his Autumn Statement and, on 22 November, in a last ditch move to save the economy, he will have to be seen more than Pulling Rabbits Out Of A Hat!